8 Questions to Ask a Roofing Contractor Before Signing a Contract

Key Takeaways

✔ Confirm proper license and insurance to ensure legal and financial protection.

✔ Check experience to gauge consistency and workmanship quality.

✔ Ask for local references to verify reputation and past performance.

✔ Understand warranty terms to know what coverage applies and for how long.

✔ Request written estimate and contract to outline clear project expectations.

✔ Review project timeline to plan around start and completion dates.

✔ Identify who will be on-site to maintain communication and job oversight.

✔ Discuss how unexpected issues are handled to avoid delays and extra costs.

Choosing the right roofing contractor is one of the most important decisions in any home improvement project. A poorly chosen contractor can lead to delays, hidden costs, and even structural damage. While many companies offer roofing services, not all deliver the same level of professionalism, accountability, or quality.

In fact, contractor-related scams and poor workmanship contribute to major financial losses across the US. As David J. Glawe, President and CEO of NICB, explains, “Contractor fraud costs hardworking Americans billions of dollars every year.”

Here are eight key questions to ask a roofing contractor before signing a contract.

8 Must-Ask Questions for Your Roofing Contractor

1. Are You Licensed and Insured?

Hiring a roofing contractor without confirming proper licensing and insurance can lead to serious risks. A license is more than a formality—it proves that the roofing company meets local requirements and follows safety and building codes. Insurance, on the other hand, protects homeowners from financial responsibility in case of accidents or property damage during the job.

Why Licensing Matters

A valid license is a sign that the contractor is recognized by the state or local authority and understands industry regulations.

Verified Qualifications: Confirms the contractor has passed required exams and has adequate training.
Legal Compliance: Ensures the work meets local building codes and zoning laws.
Consumer Protection: Offers recourse if the job is done improperly or not completed.

Types of Insurance in Roofing Projects

Insurance is a critical layer of protection during any roofing job. It shields the homeowner and the workers from costly liabilities and confirms the roofing contractor is a responsible business owner who values safety and risk management.

General Liability Insurance: Covers damage to the home or property caused by the roofing crew.
Workers’ Compensation Insurance: Protects the homeowner from being held responsible if a worker gets injured on the job.

What Homeowners Should Ask

Asking the right questions helps determine whether the contractor is both qualified and trustworthy.

Ask for Proof: A professional roofer should readily provide copies of licenses and insurance certificates.
Verify with Authorities: Homeowners can confirm the license status with local licensing boards.
Check Expiration Dates: Make sure documents are current and not set to expire during the project timeline.

2. How Long Have You Been in Business?

Choosing a roofing contractor with a solid track record can make a big difference in the quality and reliability of a roofing project. Experience in the roofing industry is more than just a number — it reflects knowledge, stability, and trust.

Why Experience Matters in Roofing

Not all roofing projects are the same. Roofs vary in structure, material, and repair needs. A contractor with years of hands-on experience has seen it all — and solved it all.

Knowledge of Materials: Experienced roofers understand the strengths and weaknesses of various roofing materials and can recommend the best option for the local climate and building type.
Code Compliance: A reliable roofing contractor stays updated on state and local building codes to ensure all work is legal and safe.
Efficient Problem-Solving: With time comes the ability to handle unexpected complications such as water damage, structural issues, or poor work from past contractors.
Refined Workmanship: Years in the business typically mean that a team has had time to perfect their craft, ensuring higher-quality installation and repairs.

Benefits of Hiring a Well-Established Roofing Company

Partnering with a roofing company that has a proven reputation gives homeowners peace of mind. It signals that the contractor is committed to staying in business and serving clients long-term.

Reputation and Trust: A roofing company that has operated for many years usually has a portfolio of completed jobs and customer reviews that reflect reliability and satisfaction.
Established Processes: The best roofing contractor will have streamlined systems for estimates, timelines, and communication, making the entire process smoother for the client.
Long-Term Warranty Support: A company that’s been around for a while is more likely to still be available if warranty claims need to be made years down the line.
Skilled Team: An experienced contractor often employs professional roofers who have been trained and tested on many types of projects, ensuring consistent results.

3. Can You Provide Local References?

Before hiring a roofing contractor, it’s important to ask for local references. Speaking with past clients in the same area helps confirm that the contractor has a trustworthy reputation and delivers quality work.

Why Local References Matter

When a roofing company shares local references, it shows they’ve worked successfully in the community. It also makes it easier to verify their past projects and understand the quality of their craftsmanship.

Community Reputation: Talking to past clients nearby helps confirm that the roofing contractor is known and trusted in the area.
Firsthand Project Insight: Homeowners can see completed work in person or ask about the quality, professionalism, and cleanup process directly.
Easier Follow-Up: If issues arise, dealing with a local roofing company makes it easier to get support or warranty service.
Proof of Experience in Local Conditions: Contractors who’ve worked in the area are familiar with local weather, building codes, and common roofing issues.

Key Questions to Ask References (And How They Help)

Asking past clients the right questions can quickly reveal whether a roofing contractor is dependable and professional. Here are three essential questions to focus on:

Were You Satisfied With the Work and Final Results? This reveals whether the roofing company delivered on its promises and met the homeowner’s expectations.
Did the Contractor Communicate Clearly and Stay on Schedule ?Helps determine if the professional roofers were organized, timely, and kept the client informed throughout the project.
Would You Hire Them Again? A strong indicator of trust. If the answer is yes, the contractor is likely a reliable roofing contractor worth considering.

4. What Is Your Warranty Coverage?

Before hiring a roofing contractor, it’s important for homeowners to understand the warranty coverage that comes with a new roof. A good warranty not only protects the investment but also reflects the confidence a reliable roofing contractor has in their workmanship and materials.

Types of Roofing Warranties

There are typically two types of warranties offered by a roofing company: workmanship warranties and material warranties. Both offer different kinds of protection.

Workmanship Warranty: Covers any mistakes or issues related to the installation. If leaks or structural issues arise due to poor labor, this warranty ensures repairs are made at no cost.
Material Warranty: Provided by the manufacturer, this covers defects in the roofing materials. If shingles or other components fail prematurely, they may be replaced or reimbursed depending on the warranty terms.

Understanding Warranty Duration

The length of a warranty can say a lot about its quality. A professional roofer should clearly outline how long each type of warranty lasts and what the coverage includes.

Short-Term Coverage (1–5 Years): Usually applies to basic workmanship warranties. These are commonly offered by newer or less-established contractors.
Standard Coverage (10–20 Years): Many reputable roofing companies offer warranties in this range, covering both labor and materials under certain conditions.
Extended or Lifetime Warranties: Provided by some of the best roofing contractors, these warranties offer long-term peace of mind but may come with specific conditions or costs for full protection.

Scope of Warranty Coverage

Homeowners should ask about what is and isn’t included in the warranty. Clear terms can prevent disputes and ensure faster resolutions if problems arise.

Inclusions: Covers leaks, faulty installation, or manufacturer defects, depending on the warranty type.
Exclusions: Typically does not cover damage from severe weather, neglect, or modifications made after installation.
Transferability: Some warranties can be transferred to a new owner, which can be a selling point when listing the home.
Claim Process: Ask how warranty claims are handled, including response time and steps involved.

5. Will You Provide a Written Estimate and Contract?

Before agreeing to any roofing work, it’s essential to ask the roofing contractor for a written estimate and formal contract. A trustworthy roofing company will never hesitate to provide these documents.

Why Written Agreements Matter

Written documents are a safeguard. They eliminate confusion about what was discussed and what will actually be delivered. Professional roofers who value their reputation are happy to provide paperwork that outlines their scope of work.

Accountability and Transparency: A written estimate shows what the homeowner is being charged for and gives a basis for comparing bids between companies. A signed contract holds the roofing contractor accountable for the services promised.
Avoids Surprises: Clear documentation of the costs and project scope helps avoid unexpected expenses or delays.
Proof of Professionalism: A best roofing contractor takes pride in their professionalism and ensures everything is clearly laid out in advance.

Key Elements to Look for in a Roofing Contract

Before signing, review the contract carefully. Each part should clearly explain the expectations, materials, and terms involved. A reliable roofing contractor will be happy to walk through each section to make sure the homeowner understands everything.

Detailed Scope of Work: Lists exactly what the roofing company will do, such as replacing shingles, inspecting underlayment, or repairing flashing.
Project Timeline: States estimated start and completion dates, including allowances for weather or unexpected delays.
Materials and Brands Used: Names specific roofing materials and manufacturers so the homeowner knows the quality and warranty attached.
Total Cost and Payment Terms: Breaks down the full cost of labor and materials, and outlines payment schedules (deposit, progress payments, final payment).
License and Insurance Information: Confirms that the professional roofers are properly licensed and insured, protecting the homeowner in case of accidents or damage.
Change Order Policy: Explains how unexpected repairs or additions are handled, including how the cost and work scope will be adjusted.

6. What Is the Project Timeline?

Understanding the timeline of a roofing project is essential before signing a contract. A reliable roofing contractor should clearly communicate when the work will begin, how long it will take, and what might delay the project.

Expected Start and Completion Dates

One of the first things to ask a roofing company is when the project will begin and when it is expected to be finished. These dates give clarity and prevent misunderstandings later.

Start Date Estimate: This is the approximate day the roofing crew will arrive to begin work. It helps homeowners prepare their property in advance.

Completion Timeframe: This includes how many days the job is expected to last, depending on the size and complexity of the roof.
Work Hours: Knowing what times the crew will be on-site helps minimize disruption to daily life.

Factors That May Affect the Schedule

Even the best roofing contractor can face delays due to factors outside their control. A trustworthy company will discuss these possibilities before the job starts, showing they are transparent and prepared.

Weather Conditions: Rain, snow, or extreme winds can pause work for safety reasons and may push the completion date.
Material Delays: Sometimes, specific roofing materials may be on backorder, which can affect when the work begins or progresses.

Hidden Structural Issues: Once the old roofing is removed, problems such as rotten decking or damaged flashing might be found. These issues can add extra time to the project.
Crew Availability: A professional roofers team may manage multiple jobs at once, so understanding how many people will be assigned to the project ensures realistic expectations.

7. Who Will Be On-Site During the Job?

A homeowner should always know who will be present during their roofing project. Not all roofing companies manage jobs the same way. Some send a full team of professional roofers, while others may hire subcontractors to complete the work.

Clarifying Roles and Responsibilities

Understanding who is responsible for each part of the job ensures accountability and smoother project management.

Project Manager or Site Supervisor: The main point of contact who oversees the job, ensures safety compliance, and handles updates.
Crew Members: The workers who handle installation, repair, or removal. A team of experienced and professional roofers can ensure quality craftsmanship.
Subcontractors: If a roofing contractor uses subcontractors, homeowners should ask if they are vetted, insured, and familiar with the contractor’s quality standards.

Ensuring Consistent Communication

Open and clear communication is essential for a successful roofing project. A professional roofing company will provide a communication plan from start to finish.

Designated Contact Person: It should be clear who the homeowner can speak to if there are questions or concerns.
Daily or Scheduled Updates: Regular updates keep the homeowner informed of progress, weather delays, or material issues.
Emergency Contact Process: There should be a reliable way to reach the team in case urgent issues arise.

Communication and Updates

Hiring a reliable roofing contractor means having a partner who provides regular updates and stays in contact if the schedule changes. Homeowners should ask how the roofing company plans to communicate any changes or delays.

Designated Point of Contact: A single person assigned to provide updates keeps things clear and efficient.
Progress Updates: Regular check-ins let the homeowner know how the job is going and if the finish date is still accurate.
Change Approvals: Any major adjustments to the schedule or scope should require homeowner approval before moving forward.

8. How Will You Handle Unexpected Issues?

Roofing projects often uncover hidden problems once work begins—like damaged wood, mold, or structural issues. It’s important to ask a roofing contractor how such surprises will be handled to avoid budget overruns and unnecessary delays.

Protocols for Addressing the Unexpected

A reliable roofing contractor should have a clear plan for handling unplanned issues while keeping the homeowner informed every step of the way.

Inspection and Documentation: Any unexpected damage should be inspected, photographed, and documented for transparency.
Client Approval Before Proceeding: No repairs or extra work should begin without the homeowner’s written or verbal approval.
Revised Estimate Provided: The contractor should explain any new costs and provide an updated estimate before work continues.

Understanding Cost Implications

Surprises during roofing jobs can affect the timeline and cost. A best roofing contractor will help clients understand how these issues are managed financially.

Clear Breakdown of Extra Charges: All additional charges should be clearly itemized, with simple explanations.
Warranty Implications: If extra repairs impact warranty coverage, the contractor should explain what changes.
Insurance Coordination (If Applicable): For storm or structural damage, the roofing company may assist in communicating with the homeowner’s insurance provider.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best time of year to replace your roof?

The best time to replace a roof is typically in the spring or fall when the weather is mild and stable. These seasons provide ideal conditions for shingles to seal properly and crews to work efficiently. Summer can also work, but extreme heat may affect materials. Winter is generally avoided due to cold temperatures and potential weather delays.

What is the average lifespan of a roof?

The average lifespan of a roof depends on the material. Asphalt shingles typically last 15–30 years, while metal, tile, and slate roofs can last 40–100 years. Factors like climate, maintenance, and installation quality also impact longevity. Regular inspections help extend a roof’s life.

How much should you pay a roofing contractor?

The cost of hiring a roofing contractor varies based on roof size, materials, and location. On average, homeowners can expect to pay between $5,000 and $15,000 for a full roof replacement. Always request multiple quotes and verify what is included in the price. However, pricing can vary significantly between contractors, so it’s recommended to consult reputable companies—such as Roofing Experts of Hyde Park—for accurate estimates and trustworthy service.

What is the difference between a roofer and a contractor?

A roofer typically refers to someone who physically installs or repairs roofs. A roofing contractor is a licensed professional or company that manages the entire roofing project, including labor, materials, permits, and warranties. Contractors may employ or subcontract roofers. The contractor holds the legal responsibility for the work.

What is a roofing contractor called?

A roofing contractor is often simply called a roofer or roofing professional. In formal terms, they may be referred to as a licensed roofing contractor or roofing company. Their role includes overseeing installation, repair, and maintenance of roofing systems. They are responsible for ensuring code compliance and project completion.

Schedule Trusted Roofing Services With a Local Expert!

Partner with Roofing Experts of Hyde Park for dependable roofing solutions backed by local experience and quality craftsmanship. Serving Hyde Park, NY, and nearby communities, our team of professional roofers delivers repairs, replacements, and installations with precision and care. Every project is handled with clear communication and a commitment to long-lasting results in Hyde Park, NY.

Call today for a free estimate and get started with Roofing Experts of Hyde Park!